Different Spin 24th January 2014
A
few days ago, I came across an article about Elle magazine’s “treatment”
towards Mindy Kaling’s cover. The photograph of this TV actress and writer, is
one of the four covers of Elle’s February issue. If you asked me, without
context, I would say I have no problems with the cover and found Mindy looking
very attractive in that picture. The quandary, as netizens have identified, is
that the three photographs of the other women featured on the cover, does not
look like Kaling’s. While the other TV stars (Zooey Deschanel, Amy Poehler and
Allison Williams) pictures are shot three-quarter length in full colour, Mindy
Kaling’s shot is cropped in close and printed in black-and-white. Almost
instantly, the images received criticism. From this, they was inference that
the magazine was being racist and mean.
“Was
Kaling’s shot in black-and-white, because she is a woman of color?”, “Was she
cropped, because she is an average size woman (and not stick thin like most
Hollywood stars)?”
These
were some of the comments found online.
Kaling, was reported to have loved the
cover. “It made me feel glamorous and cool,” she tweeted.
In all honesty, I did not find any
problems with the images – until I started reading the forum threads and articles.
I was admittedly, swayed.
This made me rethink our situation at
home. Are we reading into everything and overanalyzing matters? Are we becoming
a society that nitpicks and is overly sensitive?
Last
week, I added on to the statistic who watched the (in)famous “Najib-Kangkung”
clip. Ultimately what our Prime Minister was saying
was this: “When things are bad, you (rakyat) blame us (the government). But
when things are good, you don't give us credit."
Poor
bloke. Never easy being the boss.
Yes. I understand the message he was trying to convey. However, I think we are slowly becoming a community who thrives on finding faults instead of solutions. We are flawed humans who tend to notice the black spots on that white piece of paper.
It is obvious that that particular sound bite was edited out and blown out of proportion. He meant well, unfortunately the example he took to strengthen his case was, well, as limp as a soggy kangkung.
But with all the tension of late, I like to look at it with a glass half full. At least the netizens of Malaysia were united (regardless of their beliefs) on their social media pages. Even if it was just for a day or two, our timelines were #kangkung-fied.
I am a concerned Malaysian who fears the wedge of disunity is
getting deeper of late due to sensitive issues that have been making headlines
(and keyboard warriors busy). Being raised in a Catholic home in Sabah and
having embraced Islam a few years ago, the much talked about “Kalimah Allah” issue has struck a personal
chord in me. And because I refuse to be part of a herd mentality, I have
decided to be proactive in understanding this issue thoroughly. So as opposed
to just reading updates via my social media page, I have started attending
forums and dialogues that discusses this topic on a more comprehensive
platform; listening to both sides – basically, understanding why both parties
feel they are “right”.
Now
going back to the #kangkung issue. I was attending one of the forums the night
water spinach became the most talked about vegetable of 2014 (for now).
As
I was busy updating my twitter feed about the forum, I remember chuckling at a
tweet conversation between YB Nurul Izzah and YB Abdul Rahman Dahlan who
candidly acknowledged the green scenario and good-naturedly, laughed it off.
I
felt a glimmer of hope, even for a fleeting moment that perhaps (some) leaders
ARE able to see eye-to-eye despite their differences in politics. InshaAllah.
One
of the downsides of the internet is social media drama (no wonder TV ratings
are going down, but that’s another article all together). I think we are
becoming hyper-sensitive. In the age of smart phones and computers and our
love-hate social media, there is a compulsion to capture everything on camera
or video to upload to our various networks (guilty, guilty, GUILTY!) and to
share, share, share.
Events
can take on a dramatic life of their own and can quite often, lead to hyper
reactions without readers ever getting the full, entire story. I have read
about online petitions known to spring up, calling for boycotts of businesses
before the real story is revealed (remember the school children eating in toilets fiasco?).
Though
the Internet is a wonderful medium and offers a wealth of information, it can
distort the truth by the time it gets around to you.
As
writer VeronicaS says, “Words can be used to heal, unite, inspire, encourage
and ignite revolutions but they also be used to hurt, marginalize, denigrate
and abuse.”
Mistakes always seem larger
especially when someone is keeping tab. There has been a lot of bickering of
late and the rakyat is not happy.
When a nation with a multi-ethnic population is confronted with an economic
challenge plus unrest over religious and racial matters, one can comprehend the
angst and over-analyzing that takes place.
So, are we becoming a society that nitpicks
and is overly sensitive?
Yes we are. But instead of finger pointing, let’s find a way to find solutions how to work together again and be, in all essence, truly 1Malaysia again. It’s only the third week of January. We can still all begin on a clean slate.
Daphne enjoys her kangkung
belacan and complements this dish with sprinkles of fried salted fish. Her
hopes for 2014 is that trust between the rulers and the ruled will be
strengthened to overcome the challenges posed by the rising costs of living and
to ensure harmonious inter-ethnic relations. #positive floods her instagram
posts.
You have a blog! U write well too! Do write more, enjoy reading your stories =) Take care and Happy Chinese New Year Holidays =)
ReplyDeleteGreat insight Daph
ReplyDeleteZaid Ibrahim's In Good Faith is a good read :)